MakersClaw vs Rosply: Which Is More Trustworthy?
At a glance: verified facts
| Fact | MakersClaw | Rosply |
|---|---|---|
| Domain registered | 2026-05-20 | 2025-10-19 |
| Policy changes we track | None detected | None detected |
| Last data check | 2026-08-01 | 2026-08-01 |
From public records (company registry, RDAP, App Store metadata) and our policy snapshots — a "—" means we have no verified data for that field yet.
What the evidence shows
Both are ai agents & automation tools we track. Comparing the 3 trust dimensions measured for both:
- On company & identity, the two are effectively tied (4.5/8 vs 4.5/8).
- On data & privacy, the two are effectively tied (7.5/10 vs 7.5/10).
- Rosply leads on billing & subscription (8/8 vs 5.2/8).
Not yet measured for either tool: Product Reality, Community Reputation — this comparison covers only what we verified.
Quick verdicts
MakersClaw: MakersClaw earns a grade B (66.2/100) on our evidence-based trust rubric, measured on 3 of 5 trust dimensions. It scores well on data & privacy but only moderately on company & identity (4.5/8). We have not yet assessed product reality, so the grade is provisional.
Rosply: Rosply earns a grade B (76.9/100) on our evidence-based trust rubric, measured on 3 of 5 trust dimensions. It scores strongly on billing & subscription but only moderately on company & identity (4.5/8). We have not yet assessed product reality, so the grade is provisional.
Trust score breakdown
| Dimension | MakersClaw | Rosply |
|---|---|---|
| Company & Identity | 4.5/8 | 4.5/8 |
| Data & Privacy | 7.5/10 | 7.5/10 |
| Billing & Subscription | 5.2/8 | 8/8 |
| Product Reality | — | — |
| Community Reputation | — | — |
| Total | 66.2/100 | 76.9/100 |
What their privacy policies say about AI training
MakersClaw (policy captured 2026-06-16):
We don't use your content, prompts, or AI outputs to train any machine learning model.
Quoted verbatim from each vendor's own privacy policy — full context and more excerpts on each tool's report page.
Frequently asked questions
Is MakersClaw more trustworthy than Rosply?
Rosply currently scores higher — 77/100 vs 66/100 — across the 3 trust dimensions measured for both. That covers documented evidence only, not features or pricing.
Is MakersClaw legit?
MakersClaw currently holds trust grade B (66/100) based on 3 of 5 trust dimensions. The grade reflects only what we have measured; anything not yet assessed is marked as pending on the full report.
Is Rosply legit?
Rosply currently holds trust grade B (77/100) based on 3 of 5 trust dimensions. The grade reflects only what we have measured; anything not yet assessed is marked as pending on the full report.
More AI Agents & Automation comparisons
How this comparison works
Both tools are scored with the same five-dimension, 100-point rubric — company identity, data privacy, billing, product reality and reputation — using documented evidence only; a dimension with no evidence stays unscored instead of guessed. Read the full reports: MakersClaw trust report · Rosply trust report, or run any other tool through the trust check.